RV Type
Make and model
Floorplan
Year
2005 Newmar reviews
Liveability
4.8
Overall quality
4.8
Floorplan
4.7
Driving/towing
4.8
Factory warranty
3.5
Reviews
Stars Refinement
32 ratings and reviews
Voted most helpful review
Duwain Hunt
Reviewed on July 24, 2023
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Scottdale 3257
5.0
Pros Very easy to drive. The GM engine is very powerful and reliable.
We have lived in our Newmar in the summers for the last 20 years and we love it. Scottsdale is has excellent features. Like pocket doors in the Split Bath, Big Frig, Two ACs, Very little maintainen required. Great shades,...read more
Pros Very easy to drive. The GM engine is very powerful and reliable.
We have lived in our Newmar in the summers for the last 20 years and we love it. Scottsdale is has excellent features. Like pocket doors in the Split Bath, Big Frig, Two ACs, Very little maintainen required. Great shades, Plenty of Storage, 50amp service, I installed new Flat screen TVs and an On Demand Ht Water heater. We Love it. Two Thumbs Up!
Livability
5.0
Overall quality
5.0
Floorplan
5.0
Driving/towing
5.0
Factory warranty/support
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Jack
Reviewed on July 20, 2023
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Essex 4502
5.0
This Newmar Essex has been an absolute Pleasure to Own Since New when we took factory Delivery. It Drives and Performs with the 500 Cummins absolutely Beautiful! This Amish Built Newmar Coach is in my Opinion the absolute Best When it comes to Overall Fit and Finish! The Newmar Paint process is...read more
This Newmar Essex has been an absolute Pleasure to Own Since New when we took factory Delivery. It Drives and Performs with the 500 Cummins absolutely Beautiful! This Amish Built Newmar Coach is in my Opinion the absolute Best When it comes to Overall Fit and Finish! The Newmar Paint process is tops in the RV industry! ššŗšøš
Livability
5.0
Overall quality
5.0
Floorplan
5.0
Driving/towing
5.0
Factory warranty/support
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Jeff Harrell
Arizona
Reviewed on August 12, 2022
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Mountain Aire 4304
3.6
This motorhome was used extensively and maintained well during it's first 12 years. It was then sold and used for one trip in 3 years. The rest of the time it was parked outside and uncovered in the southern AZ desert. We purchased it in 2020 and spent about a year rehabbing. It is now in very good...read more
This motorhome was used extensively and maintained well during it's first 12 years. It was then sold and used for one trip in 3 years. The rest of the time it was parked outside and uncovered in the southern AZ desert. We purchased it in 2020 and spent about a year rehabbing. It is now in very good shape and a pleasure to drive and travel in. We are selling it only because we don't need something this large and would like to return to a 5th wheel.
Livability
4.0
Overall quality
4.0
Floorplan
3.0
Driving/towing
4.0
Factory warranty/support
3.0
Voted most helpful review
Kevin Foster
Illinois
Reviewed on February 24, 2021
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Dutch Star 3810
4.8
Newmar is by far the premium Class A motor coach. Cabinetry and construction is second to none. Even with the older coaches, Newmar tech support has been excellent. Have absolutely no complaints with our...read more
Newmar is by far the premium Class A motor coach. Cabinetry and construction is second to none. Even with the older coaches, Newmar tech support has been excellent. Have absolutely no complaints with our unit!
Livability
4.0
Overall quality
5.0
Floorplan
5.0
Driving/towing
5.0
Factory warranty/support
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Don
North Carolina
Reviewed on September 22, 2020
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Mountain Aire 3778
5.0
We could not be happier with our Newmar. We have traveled about 50,000 miles towing a PT Cruiser, cross country twice and into Canada and all up and down the East coast. It is as comfortable as any automobile we have owned, handles easily. We have owned other rvs but Newmar is the best in its price...read more
We could not be happier with our Newmar. We have traveled about 50,000 miles towing a PT Cruiser, cross country twice and into Canada and all up and down the East coast. It is as comfortable as any automobile we have owned, handles easily. We have owned other rvs but Newmar is the best in its price range as far as we are concerned. The structure, design and workmanship cannot be beat.When we are at a campground for any length of time, we often say, this is all we need to live a happy life !!
Even though it is a gas rig ( Chevy Workhorse, 8.1) we had no trouble with the Appalachian,Rocky or Cascade mountain ranges. A little slower going up some awesome roadways, but never a problem, even though we were towing.We averaged between 6.5 and 7.0 MPG.
Don't think you can do much better.
Livability
5.0
Overall quality
5.0
Floorplan
5.0
Driving/towing
5.0
Factory warranty/support
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Mis-T Adkins
Oregon
Reviewed on August 27, 2020
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Mountain Aire 4032
5.0
We owned and lived in our 2005 Newmar for 18 months. We traveled a bit at the beginning and then we were pretty stationary for the last 8 months in an RV Park on the Southern Oregon Coast. It was just my husband and myself and our 2 medium size furbabies. We bought it used, however it was in near...read more
We owned and lived in our 2005 Newmar for 18 months. We traveled a bit at the beginning and then we were pretty stationary for the last 8 months in an RV Park on the Southern Oregon Coast. It was just my husband and myself and our 2 medium size furbabies. We bought it used, however it was in near new condition with very low miles.
Everything worked and held up great. We were very thankful for the Aqua Hot water heater, it ran on the diesel from our tank and also ran our heater. So our propane lasted longer and when we did go to a āpermanentā rv space, our electric bill was very low! I learned to use the convection microwave for baking, it worked Great! The 3 burner gas stove worked great, however, to be honest, most of our cooking was done outside on our Camp Chef griddle/grill..... keeping the mess of cooking outside!! (I would totally recommend buying one!)
The cabinetry was oak and the flooring was tile in the living room, kitchen and bath. Carpet in the rear bedroom and the 2 LR slides. Both of the air conditioners worked great when they were needed. Especially on our trip to Tucson, AZ in mid-June (who plans a trip to AZ in Juneš¤)!! It was 117-119 š„µ for 4-1/2 days and the AC was on continually!
We would definitely purchase another Newmar again if the need arises! It was Very comfortable to live in. Very nice for towing and the ride was smooth!
The only thing that I was Totally unprepared for was the World Wide Web! What a fight the Internet ended up being š¬š¤š¤Æ
My frustration was endless. We did not use cable and did not have satellite.
My computer wouldnāt talk to my printerš¬ and itās Amazing how much data the television will eat up! We had Hulu for a few months. Until they let me know that we had used up All of our IP addresses (4) for the yearš³ Then we got YouTubeTV (which we still have). Make sure you have That figured out at the get go!
NOTE- RV parks say they have Internet available, but itās usually the bare minimum and certainly not enough for streaming tv.
Happy Trails!!!
Livability
5.0
Overall quality
5.0
Floorplan
5.0
Driving/towing
5.0
Factory warranty/support
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Bill Hill
Indiana
Reviewed on August 13, 2020
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Dutch Star 4009
5.0
Newmar is among the most highly rated motor homes. Newmar is made with the most discerning owner in mind. This unit is loaded with many expensive upgrades and optional equipment. Three sliders, four...read more
Newmar is among the most highly rated motor homes. Newmar is made with the most discerning owner in mind. This unit is loaded with many expensive upgrades and optional equipment. Three sliders, four awnings.
Livability
5.0
Overall quality
5.0
Floorplan
5.0
Driving/towing
5.0
Factory warranty/support
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Christine Nixon
Florida
Reviewed on March 18, 2020
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Mountain Aire 3783
5.0
Quality even at this age of the coach not one thing wrong, itās built to last, I canāt say enough. I did have to add stabilizer to improve driving. I would highly recommend this manufacturer and this...read more
Quality even at this age of the coach not one thing wrong, itās built to last, I canāt say enough. I did have to add stabilizer to improve driving. I would highly recommend this manufacturer and this coach
Livability
5.0
Overall quality
5.0
Floorplan
5.0
Driving/towing
5.0
Factory warranty/support
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Tracy
Nevada
Reviewed on March 16, 2020
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Scottsdale 3201
5.0
I love my newmar coach I have the 2005 scottsdale model strong motor great transmission mine has the cherry cabinets very well built through the whole coach I have lived in mine for 4 years and love it .fantastic company and it drives so nice very fun to...read more
I love my newmar coach I have the 2005 scottsdale model strong motor great transmission mine has the cherry cabinets very well built through the whole coach I have lived in mine for 4 years and love it .fantastic company and it drives so nice very fun to drive
Livability
5.0
Overall quality
5.0
Floorplan
5.0
Driving/towing
5.0
Factory warranty/support
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Cade Gibson
Indiana
Reviewed on February 29, 2020
RV reviewed 2005 Newmar Mountain Aire 4018
1.6
I own a Mountain Aire and we have had problems with a lot of the functionality of the unit.
1. Drive train was also a little off and would sift oddly in high terrain.
2. Engine seems to be over working with towing to the point that we would stop and let it cool before embarking on uneven...read more
I own a Mountain Aire and we have had problems with a lot of the functionality of the unit.
1. Drive train was also a little off and would sift oddly in high terrain.
2. Engine seems to be over working with towing to the point that we would stop and let it cool before embarking on uneven roads.
3.The electronics were okay, but some of the string lights would go out and the entire line would need to be replaced.
4. The leather was always wrinkling causing aesthetic issues.
5. The cabinet doors were great and held up well but the cabinets themselves were extremely thin and have no strength to them.
Livability
2.0
Overall quality
1.0
Floorplan
2.0
Driving/towing
2.0
Factory warranty/support
1.0
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4